Mohamed Noor (left) former Minneapolis police officer, leaves the Hennepin County Government Center in Minneapolis with attorney Peter Wold last month. Noor has been found guilty of shooting an unarmed civilian to death in 2017.
A Minneapolis jury has found a former police officer guilty in the 2017 fatal shooting of an unarmed woman minutes after she had called 911 to report a possible crime.
Mohamed Noor, the ex-Minneapolis officer charged in the shooting death of Justine Ruszczyk, was convicted of third-degree murder and manslaughter. He was found not guilty of intentional second-degree murder.
Ruszczyk, also known as Justine Damond, had called police on the night of July 15, 2017, to report a possible sexual assault in the alley behind her Minneapolis home.
She was shot and killed by Noor, one of the responding officers.
Noor’s defense attorneys argued throughout the monthlong trial that he fired to protect his terrified partner after hearing a thump on the squad car in the alley and then seeing a figure by the driver’s side window raising an arm.
“It’s a tragedy, but it’s not a crime,” Noor’s attorney Thomas Plunkett told jurors Monday.
Prosecutors countered that the thump was a story made up later and that Ruszczyk, approaching the squad in her pajamas that night, could not have been considered a threat.
They also presented evidence during the trial that Ruszczyk’s fingerprints were not found on the outside of the squad car and put two police use-of-force experts on the stand who argued Noor was reckless in his decision to fire.
The jury of 10 men and two women got the case Monday afternoon after three weeks of testimony. They deliberated five hours Monday and six on Tuesday.
Measles vaccination rates need to be at 93 to 95% to keep herd immunity. Otherwise, very young infants or other vulnerable people can get exposed to the virus.
George Frey/Getty Images
George Frey/Getty Images
Americans could be forgiven for not knowing that much about measles. After all, it’s been 51 years since an effective vaccine was introduced, quickly turning the disease from a common childhood experience to a rarity, and nearly two decades since the disease was declared eliminated from the U.S.
But outbreaks have surfaced throughout the country over the past few months, affecting more than 700 people.
Most of the cases are linked to people who’ve traveled abroad — to countries where measles is more common — or spread within insular and close-knit communities, like New York’s orthodox Jewish community. But now public health officials are concerned that we’ve reached a risky point where measles could regain a foothold in this country. This could still be prevented if vaccination rates in these communities go up.
Here’s what you need to know about measles, its spread, and who’s at risk.
How contagious is measles?
Measles, caused by the rubeola virus, is one of the most contagious infections diseases. If an infected person coughed in a room, 90% of non-vaccinated people in that room would become infected. The virus can linger in the air for up to two hours, according to the CDC.
Someone infected with the virus can begin spreading the disease four days before showing any outward signs of infection, making it harder for public health officials to contain outbreaks.
How common are serious complications?
Symptoms of measles include high fever, cough, runny nose, white spots inside the mouth, and rashes that spread across the skin.
While most recover from the infection, measles can lead to serious complications. About 1 in 4 individuals who contract measles will be hospitalized. 1 in 10 children with measles will develop ear infections, which can lead to permanent hearing loss. 1 in 1,000 will develop swelling of the brain (encephalitis) which can result in permanent brain damage. A similar proportion will die from the infection.
Who is most at risk of contracting and having serious complications of measles?
Unvaccinated young children have the highest risk of contracting measles, and developing serious complications from the disease. The CDC typically advises the first dose of the vaccine to be administered at 12 months, making young infants especially susceptible. However in light of the current outbreak, CDC officials recommend the vaccine for infants between 6-11 months who are travelling to countries with measles outbreaks.
What is herd immunity, and are we at risk of losing it?
Herd immunity is a term that describes how many people in a population need to be immune for the population as a whole to be protected. Herd immunity protects those in a population who, for whatever reason, can’t be safely vaccinated.
The proportion of a population that needs to be immune for herd immunity depends on the disease and how it’s transmitted.
Epidemiologists explain it like this:
100% – (1/the basic reproductive number of the disease)% = Herd Immunity Threshold
The basic reproductive number of a disease is the average number of people one person can infect in a totally susceptible population. Less contagious diseases require a smaller percentage of a population to be immune to prevent spread of a disease. But measles’ reproductive number is high, between 12-18, meaning that one person, on average, infects 12 to 18 other people.
How this works out is that 93 to 95 percent of the population must be immune to prevent a single case of measles from spreading. Above that threshold, the virus just keeps hitting walls of immunity, and can’t spread. But below that threshold, the virus can gain a foothold and spread among vulnerable members of a population.
It’s been said that measles was “eliminated” in 2000 from the U.S., but now we’re seeing a new outbreak. What’s the difference between eliminating and eradicating a disease?
According to the CDC, a disease is eliminated from a geographic region when no more endemic cases of the disease occur within that region. Outbreaks can still happen, but are triggered by travel to countries where the disease is not eliminated.
A disease is eradicated when the worldwide incidence of infection drops to zero. Smallpox is an example of a disease that has been successfully eradicated.
Measles is still present in many countries around the globe, so eradication is still a way off.
Where are the biggest outbreaks, domestically and globally?
The largest U.S. outbreaks are occurring in Rockland County and Brooklyn, New York. Washington state had over 70 cases in early 2019, though authorities recently declared the outbreak over in the Pacific Northwest, as there have been no new infections in over six weeks.
Most of these outbreaks have occurred in small, insular communities with low vaccination rates, often due to high levels of vaccine hesitancy.
Globally, recent outbreaks dwarf U.S. numbers. The biggest outbreak in the last six months has been Madagascar with just under 70,000 cases and in the last 12 months, Ukraine, India and Brazil has seen large outbreaks among other countries.
Does the vaccine’s effectiveness wane? Should adults get revaccinated?
According to the CDC, people who received two doses of the MMR vaccine are considered immune for life, and do not need to be re-vaccinated. However adults born between 1957 and 1967 should be revaccinated, as early vaccines were less effective than the vaccine available after 1967. Adults born before 1957 are assumed to have contracted the disease as a child, and thus have natural immunity.
Women who are considering getting pregnant should also check on their vaccination status, according to the CDC.